Four UX Fails in OOUX

UX & Product Architecture • Design Systems & Engineering

The four UX fails in Object-Oriented UX (OOUX) are masked, shape-shifting, broken, and isolated objects. Sophia Prater uses these patterns to diagnose why people may struggle to recognize objects, understand them across views, find their actions, or reach related records.

How do you spot the four problems?

Problem Example in a travel operations tool What to change
Masked object A proposed Offer and a supplier Booking both appear as “Trip item,” with no indication of which is which. Give each type a recognizable label and show the details people use to tell them apart.
Shape-shifting object Booking B-52 appears in search with its reference and status, then appears in the trip as an unlabeled date with no visible reference. Keep identifying cues consistent across views. Choose how much detail each view needs.
Broken object The booking’s status is in one workspace, its fare rules in another, and the cancellation action in a separate admin menu. Bring the relevant information and actions together around the booking, with access appropriate to the role.
Isolated object An agent opens a booking from search and must start a new search to find its trip, even though they can view both records. Add a contextual link from the booking to its trip where the agent needs it.

If the agent recognizes Booking B-52 but cannot find “Request cancellation,” check for a broken object. If they can act on the booking but cannot reach its trip, check for an isolated object.

How do you run a review?

Pick one object and follow it through a task. For Booking B-52, open the record from search and from its trip. Ask the agent to identify it, check whether cancellation is available, and find the related trip. Observe where they pause, look elsewhere, or mistake one record for another.

Use the object map to check which identifying fields belong on the record, where its actions should appear, and which relationships warrant a link. Fix the issue that interrupts the task first. A compact search result and a full detail page can look different while preserving the cues that help the agent recognize the booking.

Sources